For the best Benjamin Moore interior paints, my best overall pick is PRESTIGE Interior Paint and Primer in One in Revere Pewter Comparable Color and eggshell: it pairs a versatile greige shade with a practical finish for many living spaces. The satin Revere Pewter option better suits rooms that need a more washable surface, while the eggshell Navajo White pick offers a warmer, lighter direction. The main tradeoffs are finish durability versus sheen, and the appeal of a familiar color name versus the accuracy of a comparable match. These are PRESTIGE paints in colors matched to Benjamin Moore references, not Benjamin Moore-manufactured paints. Read on for the full breakdown and help matching a shade and finish to your room.
Get furniture and decor delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- Revere Pewter is the most flexible color choice here: it appears in both eggshell and satin, letting buyers choose finish based on room use rather than changing the shade.
- Eggshell Revere Pewter earns the overall spot for its balance of a widely adaptable greige and a lower-sheen finish suited to everyday living spaces.
- Satin is the practical direction for more frequent cleaning: the Revere Pewter and Edgecomb Gray satin options trade a more visible sheen for easier wipe-downs.
- The lineup is defined by color and finish, not a broad range of paint formulas: all six are PRESTIGE paint-and-primer-in-one options, so buyers should verify the exact product details and surface preparation needs.
- Comparable color names are not guarantees of an exact Benjamin Moore match: test a sample in the actual room, where lighting and existing finishes can change how a color reads.
| Benjamin Moore interior paint | Brand | Paint type | Finish | Coverage |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| PRESTIGE Interior Paint and Pr | PRESTIGE Paints | 100% acrylic latex | Eggshell | Approximately 250–400 sq. ft. per gallon |
| Prestige Paints Interior Paint | Prestige Paints | Acrylic | Satin | Approximately 325 sq. ft. per gallon |
| Prestige Paints Interior Paint | Prestige Paints | Acrylic | Eggshell | Approximately 325 sq. ft. per gallon |
| PRESTIGE Paints Interior Paint | PRESTIGE Paints | 100% acrylic latex | Satin | Approximately 250–400 sq. ft. per gallon |
| PRESTIGE Interior Paint and Pr | PRESTIGE Paints | Acrylic latex | Satin | Approximately 250–400 sq. ft. per gallon |
| PRESTIGE Paints Interior Paint | PRESTIGE Paints | Acrylic latex | Eggshell | Approximately 250–400 sq. ft. per gallon |
More Details on Our Top Picks
PRESTIGE Interior Paint and Primer in One, 1 Gallon, Eggshell, Revere Pewter Comparable Color
This is my pick for shoppers seeking a Revere Pewter-like color in eggshell without moving up to a shinier finish. Its acrylic-latex formula combines paint and primer for properly prepared drywall, plaster, stucco, and previously painted surfaces, while the finish offers more washability than flat paint. Compared with PRESTIGE’s Revere Pewter satin, this eggshell option has a softer sheen that can be a better fit for living rooms and bedrooms where glare is a concern. The tradeoff is that satin is generally the easier choice for frequent wipe-downs. Coverage is listed as 250–400 square feet per gallon, but the description warns that some colors need more than one coat. I’d also treat the color as a comparable match, not an exact Benjamin Moore formula.
Pros:- Eggshell finish balances a softer appearance with more washability than flat paint.
- Paint-and-primer formula is designed for properly prepared common interior surfaces.
- Coverage is listed at approximately 250–400 square feet per gallon.
- Soap-and-water cleanup and less than 5 g/L VOC before tinting.
Cons:- Some colors or surfaces may need multiple coats for full coverage.
- Comparable Revere Pewter color can vary with lighting, surface, sheen, and application.
Best for: Homeowners who want a low-sheen, washable finish in a Revere Pewter-inspired color for prepared living-room or bedroom walls.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need an exact Benjamin Moore color match or prioritize wipe-clean performance for heavily used walls; the satin Revere Pewter version is the better fit for frequent cleaning.
- Brand:PRESTIGE Paints
- Paint type:100% acrylic latex
- Finish:Eggshell
- Color:Comparable to Benjamin Moore Revere Pewter
- Volume:1 gallon (3.78 L)
- Coverage:Approximately 250–400 sq. ft. per gallon
- Dry and recoat time:About 1 hour to dry; recoat after 4 hours
- VOC and cleanup:Less than 5 g/L before tinting; warm water and soap
Our verdict“Choose this eggshell version for a softer Revere Pewter-inspired wall finish, but pick the satin version if easy repeated cleaning matters more.”
Prestige Paints Interior Paint and Primer in One – 1 Gallon Satin (Comparable Match to Benjamin Moore Revere Pewter)
Among these color-match options, I’d favor this one when cleanability matters more than a muted sheen. Its satin finish is described as easy to clean and mildew-resistant, making it a stronger fit for busy hallways and living areas than the Revere Pewter eggshell option. The self-priming acrylic formula is intended for properly prepared drywall, plaster, and previously painted surfaces, so it can simplify a routine repaint; it does not remove the need for sound preparation. Coverage is given as about 325 square feet per gallon, with a one-hour dry time and four-hour full-cure time in the supplied data. The tradeoffs are a more noticeable sheen than eggshell and the usual uncertainty of a comparable color match. Some shades may also take multiple coats to hide fully.
Pros:- Satin finish is easy to clean and described as mildew-resistant.
- Self-priming formula suits properly prepared drywall, plaster, and previously painted surfaces.
- Listed coverage is approximately 325 square feet per gallon.
- Low VOC formulation is listed at less than 5 g/L, with soap-and-water cleanup.
Cons:- Satin reflects more light than eggshell, which may be less suitable for buyers wanting a subdued finish.
- Comparable color may differ from Benjamin Moore Revere Pewter, and some colors may need multiple coats.
- Surface preparation remains necessary for the self-priming formula to perform as intended.
Best for: Households repainting busy hallways or living areas that want a wipeable satin finish in a Revere Pewter-inspired shade.
Not ideal for: Anyone seeking a low-sheen wall appearance or an exact Benjamin Moore color; the eggshell Revere Pewter version is a subtler finish choice.
- Brand:Prestige Paints
- Paint type:Acrylic
- Finish:Satin
- Color:Comparable match to Benjamin Moore Revere Pewter
- Volume:1 gallon
- Coverage:Approximately 325 sq. ft. per gallon
- Dry time:About 1 hour
- Full cure time:4 hours
- Model number:P400-P-HC-172BM
Our verdict“Pick this satin Revere Pewter match for busy rooms that need easier cleaning, not for a softer eggshell look or exact brand color fidelity.”
Prestige Paints Interior Paint and Primer in One – 1 Gallon – Eggshell – Navajo White (Comparable Match to Benjamin Moore)
This option makes the most sense for buyers who want a warm, Navajo White-inspired eggshell rather than a gray-leaning neutral. The listed 325-square-foot coverage and one-hour dry time put it in a similar practical range to PRESTIGE’s Revere Pewter eggshell, while the shade gives rooms a different direction: a warmer white instead of a greige. Its acrylic latex paint-and-primer formula is intended for interior use, with soap-and-water cleanup and recoating after four hours. That combination suits bedrooms, living rooms, and hallways on prepared surfaces. The limitation is familiar across these comparable-color paints: the shade may not reproduce Benjamin Moore Navajo White exactly, and full hiding can take multiple coats. I’d choose it for the color family and finish, not as a guaranteed one-coat shortcut.
Pros:- Warm Navajo White comparable shade offers a different palette from the Revere Pewter greige options.
- Eggshell finish provides a lower-gloss look with washability.
- Listed coverage is approximately 325 square feet per gallon.
- Low-VOC acrylic latex formula dries in about an hour and cleans up with soap and water.
Cons:- Comparable Navajo White color may vary from the original Benjamin Moore shade.
- Some colors may require multiple coats for full hiding.
- The product is intended for prepared surfaces; the self-priming description does not replace surface preparation.
Best for: Decorators seeking a warm white, eggshell wall color for bedrooms, living rooms, or hallways who are comfortable with a comparable match.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need a precise Benjamin Moore Navajo White match or guaranteed single-coat coverage; the provided data allows for color variation and extra coats.
- Brand:Prestige Paints
- Paint type:Acrylic
- Finish:Eggshell
- Color:Navajo White, comparable to Benjamin Moore
- Volume:1 gallon
- Coverage:Approximately 325 sq. ft. per gallon
- Full cure time:4 hours
- Weight:12 pounds
- Model number:P300-P-947BM
Our verdict“Choose this for a warm white eggshell look on prepared interior walls, while allowing for color variation and possible extra coats.”
PRESTIGE Paints Interior Paint and Primer in One, 1 Gallon, Satin, Comparable to Benjamin Moore Edgecomb Gray
I rank this as the Edgecomb Gray-inspired satin choice for buyers who want a neutral with a wipeable finish. Its acrylic latex formula is designed for prepared drywall, plaster, and previously painted walls; compared with the Navajo White eggshell, it shifts both the color direction toward gray-beige and the finish toward greater sheen. That makes it a practical candidate for hallways or living spaces where cleaning is part of the brief. The paint dries in about an hour, can be recoated after four, and cleans up with soap and water. Its main compromise is that a satin surface can show more sheen than eggshell, while the comparable color is not guaranteed to look identical to Benjamin Moore’s Edgecomb Gray. Stained or glossy surfaces also need a stain-blocking primer sealer first.
Pros:- Satin finish is easy to clean and described as mildew-resistant.
- Paint-and-primer formula is suited to properly prepared interior walls.
- Dries in about one hour and can be recoated after four hours.
- Soap-and-water cleanup and less than 5 g/L VOC before tinting.
Cons:- Satin sheen is more reflective than eggshell and may not suit buyers seeking a softer appearance.
- Color can vary with lighting, surface, sheen, and application.
- Stained or glossy surfaces require a stain-blocking primer sealer before painting.
Best for: Homeowners choosing an Edgecomb Gray-like neutral for prepared walls in hallways and living spaces where a satin finish is useful.
Not ideal for: Anyone wanting a low-sheen finish, a guaranteed exact Edgecomb Gray match, or a direct application over stained or glossy surfaces without primer sealer.
- Brand:PRESTIGE Paints
- Paint type:100% acrylic latex
- Use:Interior
- Finish:Satin
- Color match:Comparable to Benjamin Moore Edgecomb Gray
- Volume:1 gallon
- Coverage:Approximately 250–400 sq. ft. per gallon
- Dry and recoat time:About 1 hour to dry; recoat after 4 hours
- VOC:Less than 5 g/L before tinting
Our verdict“Choose this for a cleanable, Edgecomb Gray-inspired satin finish on prepared walls, but prime challenging surfaces and expect a comparable rather than exact match.”
PRESTIGE Interior Paint and Primer in One, 1 Gallon, Satin, White
For a straightforward white repaint, I’d choose this over the tinted Revere Pewter and Edgecomb Gray satin options when the goal is a neutral base rather than a Benjamin Moore-inspired shade. The paint-and-primer acrylic latex is intended for drywall, plaster, stucco, and previously painted surfaces, and its washable satin finish suits bedrooms, hallways, and living rooms that see regular use. Drying takes about an hour, with recoating after four hours if needed. That makes it a practical fit for planned room refreshes, though not a reason to rush preparation or recoat ahead of the label directions. The supplied coverage range is 250–400 square feet per gallon. This white version offers no specialized color-match claim, and stained or glossy surfaces still call for a stain-blocking primer sealer.
Pros:- White satin finish works for general-purpose interior repaints.
- Paint-and-primer formula is designed for common prepared surfaces, including drywall and plaster.
- Washable finish and soap-and-water cleanup suit regularly used rooms.
- Dries in about one hour, with recoating possible after four hours.
Cons:- Coverage of 250–400 square feet per gallon means project needs can vary, and some colors may require more than one coat.
- Stained or glossy surfaces need a stain-blocking primer sealer first.
- The listing provides no Benjamin Moore comparable color specification.
Best for: Homeowners repainting prepared interior walls white who want a washable satin finish for bedrooms, hallways, or living rooms.
Not ideal for: Shoppers seeking a specific Benjamin Moore comparable shade or painting directly over stained or glossy surfaces without first using a stain-blocking primer sealer.
- Brand:PRESTIGE Paints
- Paint type:Acrylic latex
- Use:Interior
- Finish:Satin
- Color:White
- Volume:1 gallon
- Coverage:Approximately 250–400 sq. ft. per gallon
- Dry and recoat time:About 1 hour to dry; recoat after 4 hours
- Suitable surfaces:Drywall, plaster, stucco, or previously painted surfaces
Our verdict“Pick this for a practical white satin repaint on prepared walls, not when you need a named Benjamin Moore color match.”
PRESTIGE Paints Interior Paint and Primer, 1 Gallon, Eggshell, Linen White Comparable Color
This is a practical pick for buyers seeking a Linen White comparable color in a washable eggshell finish, rather than a paint specifically made by Benjamin Moore. Its paint-and-primer formulation suits properly prepared drywall, plaster, stucco, and previously painted surfaces, giving it broader everyday usefulness than choosing by color alone. Compared with PRESTIGE’s Navajo White comparable eggshell, this option centers on Linen White; compared with the Revere Pewter comparable eggshell, it offers a white rather than a greige direction. Coverage is listed at 250–400 square feet per gallon, though some colors may need another coat. The color can also shift with lighting and application, and stained or glossy surfaces need a stain-blocking primer sealer first. I’d choose it for a soft-white room refresh, not for an exact Benjamin Moore color match.
Pros:- Paint-and-primer formulation for properly prepared common interior surfaces
- Washable eggshell finish suits rooms where walls need routine cleaning
- Soap-and-water cleanup
- Listed coverage of approximately 250–400 square feet per gallon
Cons:- Comparable color is not a guarantee of an exact Benjamin Moore match
- Some colors may require more than one coat
- Stained or glossy surfaces require a stain-blocking primer sealer
Best for: DIY painters choosing a Linen White-like shade for properly prepared interior walls who want an eggshell surface that can be washed.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need an exact Benjamin Moore color match, or painters covering stained or glossy surfaces without adding a suitable primer sealer.
- Brand:PRESTIGE Paints
- Paint type:Acrylic latex
- Use:Interior
- Finish:Eggshell
- Color:Linen White comparable color
- Container size:1 gallon
- Coverage:Approximately 250–400 sq. ft. per gallon
- Dry time / recoat time:1 hour / 4 hours
- VOC:Less than 5 g/L before tinting
Our verdict“Choose this for a washable, soft-white eggshell finish on prepared interior surfaces, but skip it if an exact Benjamin Moore match is essential.”
How We Picked
I ranked these six options by the decisions buyers can make from the supplied product details: color versatility, finish suitability, and clarity of use. I gave the lead position to eggshell Revere Pewter because its greige color has broad room-to-room potential, and eggshell avoids the stronger shine of satin in spaces where a softer look is preferred. The satin Revere Pewter follows for buyers who put wipeability ahead of a more subdued appearance. The other shades fill distinct needs: Navajo White and Linen White lean light and warm, Edgecomb Gray offers another neutral in satin, and plain white provides a straightforward option.
The supplied listings do not establish independent performance results, exact color-match accuracy, coverage, or washability claims, so I do not treat those as proven differences. I rank by the choices the product names actually identify, rather than assume one color or finish has superior paint performance. Since every option is a PRESTIGE paint-and-primer-in-one listing, the lineup offers limited formula variety; buyers should check the current label for surface compatibility, application guidance, and finish details before ordering. A Benjamin Moore color reference signals a comparable shade, not paint made by Benjamin Moore.
| Benjamin Moore interior paint | Finish | Color | Coverage |
|---|---|---|---|
| PRESTIGE Interior Paint and Pr | Eggshell | Comparable to Benjamin Moore Revere Pewter | Approximately 250–400 sq. ft. per gallon |
| Prestige Paints Interior Paint | Satin | Comparable match to Benjamin Moore Revere Pewter | Approximately 325 sq. ft. per gallon |
| Prestige Paints Interior Paint | Eggshell | Navajo White, comparable to Benjamin Moore | Approximately 325 sq. ft. per gallon |
| PRESTIGE Paints Interior Paint | Satin | — | Approximately 250–400 sq. ft. per gallon |
| PRESTIGE Interior Paint and Pr | Satin | White | Approximately 250–400 sq. ft. per gallon |
| PRESTIGE Paints Interior Paint | Eggshell | Linen White comparable color | Approximately 250–400 sq. ft. per gallon |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Benjamin Moore Interior Paints
Before choosing a can, I would separate three decisions that are easy to blur together: the color reference, the sheen, and the room’s demands. These choices affect how the paint looks in changing light and how the finished wall handles routine care. The following checks help prevent a common mistake: choosing by a color name alone.
Treat a Comparable Color as a Starting Point
A comparable color label helps identify the intended direction, but it does not promise an exact match to a Benjamin Moore paint chip or a surface already painted in that brand. Different paint bases, tinting systems, and batches can affect the result. I would compare a sample against the actual room’s trim, flooring, and fabrics rather than rely on a screen image or the color name. Check it in morning and evening light, since greiges and whites can shift noticeably across a day. If the new paint must meet existing Benjamin Moore walls precisely, test before committing to the full room. That extra step matters more than choosing between two similarly named neutrals.
Choose Sheen for How the Room Is Used
Eggshell generally gives walls a softer, less reflective look than satin, while satin’s added sheen can make routine wiping more practical. Sheen can also make wall texture and patching easier to see, especially under strong side lighting. That means a busy hallway may benefit from a washable finish, while a living room with uneven walls may look calmer in a lower sheen. Do not assume the same finish is right for every wall just because the color works throughout the home. Confirm the product label’s cleaning and application guidance before choosing based on sheen alone. A finish change can alter how a color appears, even when the tint is unchanged.
Compare Warm and Cool Neutrals in Your Own Light
Names such as Revere Pewter, Edgecomb Gray, Navajo White, and Linen White suggest different neutral directions, but room lighting can change their apparent warmth and depth. North-facing light, warm bulbs, wood floors, and nearby paint colors all influence what the eye sees. I would place sample patches on more than one wall instead of judging a small card in a single spot. Leave them visible across different times of day and beside permanent surfaces such as countertops or tile. A common misstep is selecting a white or greige from an online image, then discovering that it clashes with the room’s undertones. Test the shade in context before choosing a whole-room quantity.
Understand What Paint-and-Primer-in-One Does—and Does Not—Mean
A paint-and-primer-in-one product can simplify routine repainting, but the label does not mean every surface is ready for paint without preparation. Stains, glossy coatings, bare material, repairs, or major color changes may call for separate preparation or a dedicated primer. Skipping that step can lead to uneven coverage or adhesion problems, regardless of the color or finish selected. Check the surface instructions and prepare the wall by cleaning, repairing, and sanding where appropriate. If the project involves a difficult surface, ask the seller or manufacturer whether the listed formula suits it. The convenience claim should guide expectations, not replace a surface check.
Compare the Full Project, Not Just the Gallon Label
Coverage, number of coats, surface condition, and the need for primer all affect how much paint a room requires. I would measure the project and compare the product’s stated coverage with the actual wall area, then allow for extra paint for touch-ups if the color will be hard to reproduce later. One gallon may not cover the same usable area in every room, especially where walls are porous or textured. Check the current product details for coverage and recoat timing rather than assume they are identical across listings. A low-sheen neutral that needs extra preparation may take more work than a satin option on a ready-to-paint wall. Planning around the whole job helps avoid an interrupted project or mismatched later batch.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are these paints made by Benjamin Moore?
No. The products in this roundup are listed as PRESTIGE paints with colors described as comparable to Benjamin Moore references. A comparable-color label does not mean the paint is manufactured by Benjamin Moore or guarantee a precise match to its original paint. If brand identity or exact coordination matters for your project, check the product listing and test a sample against the Benjamin Moore color in your room. This distinction is especially important when touching up an existing wall, since even close shades can look different side by side.
Should I choose eggshell or satin for the Revere Pewter option?
I would lean toward eggshell when a softer wall appearance matters more than frequent wiping, and toward satin when the room sees regular contact or cleanup. Satin reflects more light, which can make surface irregularities easier to notice. The Revere Pewter listings make this a useful direct comparison because the shade reference is shared while the finish changes. Check the product’s care instructions and assess the wall condition before deciding. Testing both finishes in the room can show how much the sheen changes the color’s appearance.
Can I use the satin paints in a bathroom or kitchen?
Satin may be a practical finish for rooms where walls need more regular cleaning, but the listing details here do not establish suitability for every damp or high-heat area. Check the current label for approved applications and any ventilation or surface requirements. Bathrooms and kitchens also differ: a well-ventilated powder room is not the same environment as a shower enclosure or a wall beside a stove. Prepare the surface correctly and follow the manufacturer’s instructions. Do not treat a satin sheen alone as proof that a paint is designed for moisture exposure.
Will one coat cover my existing wall color?
The supplied product names do not confirm one-coat coverage, and the result can depend on the existing color, wall condition, application method, and chosen shade. A lighter color over a dark or uneven wall may need additional coats or separate preparation. Read the current product directions and plan for the possibility of more than one coat rather than budgeting the project around a one-coat assumption. Paint a test area and let it dry fully before judging coverage. That check can reveal whether repairs or primer are needed before the full application.
Which option should I choose if I am unsure between the white and greige shades?
Start with the room’s permanent finishes and the mood you want, not the shade name alone. Navajo White and Linen White point toward lighter, warmer choices, while Revere Pewter and Edgecomb Gray provide greige or gray-leaning neutral directions. The exact appearance depends on light and neighboring colors, and the listings do not establish that one shade will suit every home. Sample the finalists on separate walls near the floor, trim, and furniture they need to work with. If you want one shade across several rooms, test it in each room before settling on a full project quantity.
Conclusion
For most buyers choosing from this lineup, I recommend PRESTIGE eggshell Revere Pewter Comparable Color as the best overall: it combines a versatile greige reference with a restrained finish. The best value in practical versatility is satin Revere Pewter for buyers who want the same color direction with a more wipeable finish; I cannot rank monetary value without verified price and coverage details. There is no clearly supported premium formula in this group, since all six listings are PRESTIGE paint-and-primer-in-one options. For beginners, I would start with eggshell Revere Pewter and sample it before buying for the whole room; for a lighter, warmer look, compare Navajo White with Linen White. Choose satin Edgecomb Gray or white when that specific shade direction is the priority, and verify the surface guidance and comparable-color match before purchase.
Halloween Picks
halloween
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
